Say it isn't so: Study of New York City pedestrian accidents prove women are better drivers
Safety advocates from as far away as San Francisco are encouraging city leaders across the country to conduct a comprehensive traffic study similar to the one unveiled last week in Manhattan, which examined ways to reduce the high number of serious and fatal New York City pedestrian accidents.
As our New York City accident attorneys reported on our New York Injury Lawyer Blog, more than 7,000 pedestrian accidents were studied as city leaders formed a comprehensive plan to reduce accidents. Last year, more than half of the city's traffic fatalities involved pedestrians. Planned improvements include the installation of more than 1,500 countdown signals at intersections.
But safety advocates keep pouring over the data looking for additional nuggets: Like the fact that New York City motorcycle accidents are 18 times more likely to be fatal than accidents involving the occupants of a passenger car.
The New York Times even argues that the study debunks the myth that women are lousy drivers. Eighty percent of all fatal pedestrian accidents over the last five years involved male drivers -- a statistic far too one-sided to be explained away by male dominance in roles like cab and bus drivers. Besides, the study also showed that such commercial vehicles are only responsible for about 20 percent of pedestrian accidents.
"The statistic would seem to put to rest, for good, the Mars versus Venus question of who is better behind the wheel," The Times article states. "And to confirm what auto insurance companies -- and at least half the city (women, that is) -- knew all along."
Traffic safety experts and social scientists point to the male propensity for aggression and risk taking. They also argue that men are more likely to drink and drive, avoid wearing seat belts, speed or take other excessive risks while behind the wheel.
Not only do men take more risks behind the wheel, they are more likely to be injured or killed in a pedestrian accident. Boys ages 5 to 17 had the highest number of death and serious injuries, with 785 -- more than twice the number for girls in that age range.










